When deciding to build a backyard pool, one of the biggest questions you’ll face is whether to choose a saltwater or chlorine system. Both options have their advantages and drawbacks, and the best pool type really depends on your preferences, budget, and long-term maintenance goals.
At Pools Out Back, we help Amarillo homeowners design custom pools that fit their lifestyle—so we’re here to break down the pros and cons of each system to help you make the right decision.
Saltwater Pools: The Pros
Gentler on Skin and Eyes
Saltwater pools use a salt chlorinator to convert salt into chlorine. As a result, the chlorine levels in saltwater pools are lower and more stable. This leads to water that feels softer and is less irritating on skin and eyes.
Lower Ongoing Chemical Costs
Because the chlorinator continuously generates chlorine through a process called electrolysis, you don’t need to purchase and add chlorine to your pool. While regular monitoring and adjustments are necessary, saltwater pools often lead to lower chemical costs over time.
Easier Day-to-Day Maintenance
Saltwater pools tend to maintain more consistent chlorine levels, reducing the time spent testing and adjusting chemicals. For homeowners who want a “set it and forget it” system, this can be one of the most attractive benefits. During swimming season, most saltwater pool owners only need to test their water about once a week, and often find little adjustment is necessary.
Saltwater Pools: The Cons
Higher Upfront Costs
While they can save money over time, saltwater pools come with a higher initial investment. The salt chlorine generator itself is an added expense, and installation can cost more than a standard chlorine system.
Potential for Equipment Corrosion
Salt is naturally corrosive, and over time, it can wear down certain materials in your pool’s equipment, especially if not properly maintained. Pool heaters, lighting fixtures, and handrails may be more vulnerable without the right precautions.
More Complex Repairs
Saltwater systems involve more advanced equipment, which may require specialized repair services if something goes wrong. At Pools Out Back, our team of experts can simplify the process and handle saltwater pool repairs with ease.
Chlorine Pools: The Pros
Lower Initial Installation Costs
Traditional chlorine pools are generally less expensive to install, often a few thousand dollars less than saltwater setups. For homeowners focused on upfront costs, this can be an appealing option.
Simple and Familiar System
Chlorine pools have long been the standard, so supplies are widely available, and most pool technicians are familiar with servicing them. At Pools Out Back, we install and maintain both systems, so you’re in good hands either way.
Fast Shock Treatments
If your pool water turns cloudy or develops algae, shocking a chlorine pool is quick and effective. Chlorine also tends to act faster in sanitizing the water compared to salt-generated chlorine.
Chlorine Pools: The Cons
Frequent Chemical Handling
Chlorine pool maintenance requires regular monitoring and adjustment of chemical levels. You’ll need to handle and store chlorine safely, which adds to your routine workload. During swimming season, it is recommended you check your chemical levels once or twice a week, especially if you’re using the pool frequently.
Skin and Eye Irritation
Traditional chlorine levels can cause red eyes, dry skin, and that familiar “pool smell”, especially if not properly balanced. This can be a drawback for families with sensitive skin or allergy concerns.
Ongoing Chemical Costs
Although chlorine pools are cheaper to install, the cost of chemicals can add up over the years. These recurring expenses are important to consider in your long-term pool budget.
So, What’s the Best Pool Type for You?
The right type of pool for you will depend on your budget and long-term maintenance goals.
If you want water that’s low-maintenance, gentle on skin and eyes, and are comfortable with a higher initial cost, a saltwater pool might be your best fit. If you’re looking for a lower upfront investment and a familiar approach to pool care, a chlorine pool is a great option.
Ready to Build Your Dream Pool?
At Pools Out Back, we install both saltwater and chlorine systems and are happy to walk you through the pros and cons in person. We understand that every backyard and every family is unique. That’s why we offer free estimates and custom designs to fit your needs, your budget, and your lifestyle.
Whether you’re ready to dive into your new pool project or just have questions about chlorine pool maintenance or saltwater pool benefits, contact us today or stop by. Let’s build the perfect pool for your Amarillo home together!
